Astrology Skepticism
Astrology is an unbelievably old craft, but there is at least one way to look for The Truth that is younger: to doubt stuff. As long as astrology exists, some people don’t (or don’t want) think that it’s working, or that it can function, or actually it can be useful. For approximately the same time, most of the same objections were repackaged to astrologers in various forms.
If you are a individual who utilizes astrology to improve, enhance and improve your lives… Or you are only accessible to the concept, even if… Take a few minutes to get acquainted with the most popular statements used by sceptics to pok traps. Then when somebody attempts to create you feel stupid next moment, you can cause some real thinking.
Astrology Skepticism Astrology unbelievably craft The Truth younger doubt stuff long astrology exists people working function For time objections repackaged astrologers forms individual utilizes astrology improve enhance improve lives accessible concept Take minutes acquainted popular statements sceptics pok traps Then attempts create feel stupid moment real thinking Astrology incredibly ancient art method seeking The Truth older doubting long astrology didn didn works work fact whatsoever For time astrologers faced objections repackaged forms person astrology life happier meaningful place open idea minutes familiarize common arguments skeptics poke holes Then time feel foolish provoke real thought THE OBJECTION There Signs constellation Ophiuchus THE RESPONSE That Signs The Ophiuchus lot press couple years news story hit claiming 13th constellation Zodiac Ophiuchus meant weren Virgo You surprised long distinction Astronomy Astrology knew When astrologers refer Signs referring divides sky equal sections fact roughly correspond constellations Signs names But Signs dependent constellations case Pisces larger chunk calendar Cancer visually smaller constellation This covers argument The Signs moving time backdrop stars called precession Taurus Aries THE OBJECTION Astrology doesn force gravity electromagnetism planets influence THE RESPONSE Take pill People acetylsalicylic acid commonly Aspirin long time rid pain inflammation Long Aspirin developed people molecule salicin purposes Its dates history form willow bark tea wintergreen However wasn 1970s actual physiological mechanism salicin works pinned Not knowing works doesn doesn work THE OBJECTION How 12th people Earth kind day THE RESPONSE Obviously Sun Signs great double edged sword modern astrology hand birthday Sign personality traits Sign Astrology humans lot complex Most people astrology birthday easy people Moon Sign Mars Sign Jupiter Sign bearing life personality parents alcoholics doesn automatically business bankrupt doesn subsequent ventures fail And Scorpio seeking revenge THE OBJECTION Astrologers making money gullible THE RESPONSE Got stock tips The argument scam money interesting fact dismiss validity pretty person living Drugs work pharmaceutical companies exploiting fears sick depressed psychiatry scam rained company picnic meteorology fraud pay investment adviser plenty STILL billionaire mind Okay validity argument Long term stock predictions demonstrated time accurate throwing darts Stock market choosing investments Also LOT ways living pay astrologer investment adviser THE OBJECTION Other planets discovered Astrology began Astrology accurate THE RESPONSE bone pick This favorite objections Astrology fun pick Long medicine determined cells differentiate body parts medicine managed figure body parts Yes shockingly thousands years healers difference broken fibula infected wound knew splint plaster herbs This college degrees Likewise roles Sun Moon birth chart remain Uranus Neptune work THE OBJECTION Where proof Astrology works THE RESPONSE Can borrow cup Dark Matter Astrology thousands years fallen favor intelligentsia science incredibly good idea sufficient funding properly test experiment Also lot ideas mainstream science believes demonstrated properly Billions dollars salaries scientific instruments finding dark matter mysterious force substance explains Universe appears work haven That doesn Physics Department local University filled artists THE OBJECTION Isn Astrology form bigotry THE RESPONSE Sure bigot Yes people Aquarius unfaithful hire Gemini scattered dog Virgo messy That sort isn astrology fault people biases The impulses people nose based ethnicity religion handedness belief astrology easily twisted astrological terms Having Yes Virgo dogs easy housebreak experience THE OBJECTION Astrology nonsense people THE RESPONSE fun dogma walk isn When doubt skeptics love invoke Confirmation Bias dismiss astrology Confirmation Bias idea tend agree enforced correct left handed accountants crooks read news story left handed accountant convicted fraud Aha remember story ages won notice remember handed accountant charged fraud importantly won notice accountants handedness honest people That Confirmation Bias works fact easy trap fall skeptics repeating tired unexamined objections astrology deeper digging Back January 1998 lunch Michael Shermer editor Skeptic Magazine admire Shermer magnificent job limited resources making public aware clear thinking skeptical attitude necessity evidence During conversation mentioned thought skeptics knew astrology study subject criticizing His wife Why teach That main purposes website Before discuss astrology works subject practiced Before asks evidence evaluate evidence The lessons learn astrology astrology They skeptics science demands knowledge subject evaluation Skeptics trouble discredit astrology fail simple All astrologers Please provide evidence prove astrology works That The burden proof ALWAYS people claim true The ball astrologer court discussion Unfortunately skeptics This problems obvious subject Not rush print bothering check write flaws logic Here errors committed The Andrew Franknoi professor astronomy list Ten Embarrassing Questions Astrologers Personally questions list included textbook logic chapter titled Errors Logic How Avoid Them examine list Question What likelihood twelfth population kind day Answer Well agree Those called horoscope columns newspapers designed publicity stunt increase circulation Unfortunately worked result people astrology sign Absolutely untrue Sun sign columns emphatically real astrology denounce turn However Franknoi familiar field Question Why moment birth conception crucial astrology suspect reason astrologers adhere moment birth astrological theory Almost client born difficult identify person moment conception Answer The reason astrologers time birth birth completely formed human After conception fertilized egg But notice subtle shift The real issue Does astrology work assertions astrologers tested Franknoi change Well doesn sound true When quantum mechanics proposed didn sound years accepted Opponents called Quacker Mechanics Whether sounds proof Question mother womb astrological influences birth cubicle steak Answer This complex question fallacy famous question beat wife The question assumes facts evidence Franknoi apparent procedure moment birth propose ridiculous reason trouble ridiculing making error strawman fallacy Please notice question contradicts previous moment conception mother body shield vice versa The proper procedure investigate Then reason reversing order Franknoi conclusion astrology work good reason For decades explain bumblebees fly They violate laws aerodynamics Following Franknoi procedure conclude bees didn fly form illusion Question astrologers good claim richer Answer Really Franknoi doesn sound question smart rich uneducated relatives college graduates family gatherings The answer knowing valuable making money skills You question economists financial analysts Not billionaire Bill Gates Michael Dell hand dropouts And question hominum fallacy refute opponent slander The main questions repeat Does astrology work Can tested Question Are horoscopes discovery outermost planets incorrect Answer physics discovery relativity quantum mechanics incorrect Does discovery element invalidate previous knowledge chemistry Yes horoscopes centuries complete Yes missing totally wrong The knowledge doctors today dwarfs doctors years Are cures doctors achieved 1800 wrong didn today Will cures doctors achieve year wrong knowledge discovered future Question Shouldn condemn astrology form bigotry civilized society deplore systems judge individuals sex skin color national origin accidents birth Yet astrologers boast evaluate people based accident birth positions celestial objects Isn refusing Leo hire Virgo bad refusing Catholic hire black person Answer This clear error called argumentum hominum called argument insult Does astrology work Never mind Astrologers BAD Why bigots listen Tell doctor Franknoi genetics determine probability people diseases accident birth Can knowledge insurance companies instance deny coverage Why argument doctors perform procedures condemned bigots Question Why schools astrology disagree Astrologers disagree fundamental issues craft account precession Earth axis planets celestial objects included importantly personality traits cosmic phenomena Read astrology columns reading astrologers interpretations astrology science proponents claim practitioners converging consensus theory thousands years complex question fallacy Franknoi assuming facts evidence Scientific ideas generally converge time tested laboratory evidence contrast systems based superstition personal belief tend diverge practitioners carve separate niches jockeying power income prestige Answer case Franknoi doctor tells operation needed bother opinion Medicine science isn First disagreements field Secondly disagreements astrologers great Thirdly certification astrologers Anyone astrologer reading book knowledge field contrast imagine chaos health field doctor difference Harvard graduate decided hang shingle This situation slowly remedied There astrological organizations AFA NCGR provide certification examination differing opinions personality traits cosmic phenomena talk astrologers position Your comment converging consensus partially true astrologer That situation mentioned changing That practitioners carving separate niches jockeying power income prestige answer laughing Most astrologers work time pay Research pay small sums offered magazine articles Most work love field money consideration start companies And turn play skeptic evidence Tell Franknoi based order pose questions names practitioners carving separate niches power income prestige achieving Questions astrological influence carried force planets dominate effects astrology attributed gravity tidal forces magnetism invoked astrological school physics student calculations newborn baby These worked cases Roger Culver Philip Ianna book Astrology True False For obstetrician delivers child turns times gravitational pull Mars billion times tidal force Answer gravitation tidal effects forces operational Yes astrologers wrongly postulated astrology work But fact wrong identifying source And individual astrologers astrological schools Franknoi suggests And Franknoi putting cart horse Instead investigating fact astrological phenomenon good reason fashion Simon Newcomb famous mathematician proved heavier air machine fly proved wrong bicycle mechanics read proof Subjectivity place science The proper scientific procedure check reason Question astrological influence carried unknown force independent distance All long range forces universe weaker objects But expect Earth centered thousands years astrological influences depend distance The Mars horoscope identical planet Sun Earth times force dependent distance revolutionary discovery science changing fundamental notions Answer agree force revolutionary discovery science changing fundamental notions What point Franknoi Are scientists supposed afraid Quantum mechanics overthrew fundamental notions Would advised Max Planck publishing reason purpose science advance knowledge defend fundamental notions hear answer Question astrological influences depend distance astrology stars galaxies quasars Answer THERE ASTROLOGY STARS AND THERE HAS BEEN FOR THOUSANDS YEARS Furthermore books subject print The fact question lack familiarity subject criticizing Please study criticize Next list titled statements titled Why Astrology Bunk compiled Terry Sandbek psychologist Here reasons astrology stacking marbles football Astrology contributed knowledge planets human behavior Information astrologers worse psycho babble astrology accomplished thousands years Science years moon cures illness brought radio movies computers When compare achievements science astrology laughably insufficient Notice Sandbek Franknoi avoids questions Does astrology work How tested order indulge hominums Worse psycho babble Psycho babble complete nonsense Exactly worse complete nonsense And wasn term psycho babble originally ridiculous pronouncements psychologists Could projection First astrology performs astrologers claim good psychological test predictor future trends Secondly claiming astrology laughably insufficient didn bring radio computers Sandbek committing error comparing apples oranges Art literature didn Neither astronomy And science biology contribution whatsoever automobile production Are condemn Sandbek continues Astrology works pigeon paying money complete attention attentive warm called halo resist temptation indulge error argumentum hominum circumstantial The exact charge leveled Sandbek field psychology Carl Rogers years matter therapist theoretical orientation psychoanalytic gestalt cure rate remains psychotherapist remain nameless told patient hysterical woman threatened suicide terrified Finally told cured dismissed checked acting cured astrologer sees client times year Psychologists week And shrinks charge Tell Sandbek possibility case projection number psychologists astrology evaluation tool Jungians Sandbek Your sign continually 000 years cosmological phenomenon called precession equinoxes astrologer explain astronomy student What sign zodiac position For astrological sign Aries born sign Pisces Funny huh This red herring question First Sandbek signs shift years 000 The 000 year figure time period required Earth orbit completely precess Sun Secondly TWO zodiacs tropical sidereal The vast majority astrologers tropical zodiac signs changed Thirdly constellations exist Astrologers Constellations place markers The assertions Sandbek dealt Marriages incompatible signs problems divorces marriages compatible signs The Marines Special Forces Armed Services men warlike signs men peaceful signs This strawman fallacy Put mouth refute Astrology based entire horoscope Sun sign astrologer asserted marriages compatible signs people warlike signs armed services And wrong Astrology readings vague meaningless Read room people people signs belongs referring misnamed Sun sign astrology readings agree Those real astrology readings labeled Real astrology readings specific events times You beating dead horse Sandbek Astrologers fetish They names Greeks arbitrarily planets How foolish impossible planet 1997 QB1 people born sign mathematicians First names arbitrarily Could ancient Greeks observed Secondly planet Uranus named Greeks fact years named discoverer William Herschel The procedure astrologers figure planet influence calculate position Uranus horoscopes charts examples horoscopes Uranus horoscopes ofLenny Bruce Salvador Dali Isadora Duncan Uranus correlate traits rebelliousness increased originality These traits totally unassociated Greek legends Uranus Incidentally planet Saturn astrology planet conservatism Greek myths Uranus established power Saturn rebelled overthrew astrologers fetish The problem twins astrologers time seconds minutes difference person aspects astrologers claim The degree sign Mid Heaven degree minutes There change Rising Sign reasoning applies homoziogot twins amazingly answer question fraternal twins astrologer knowledge claims astrological recognize influences people genetic kitten born time place human baby astrological factors great communication ability human talk write The cat meow Again avoidance main questions Does astrology work How tested This instance lazy student syndrome Some students spend time effort thinking reasons shouldn study subject work Now James Amazing Randi gentleman lives Randi familiar work exposure fraud stupidity calling life shortage material Randi commended efforts remind easy fooled demonstration bunch college students They told astrologer preparing personal horoscope evaluate Most students horoscope fit tee didn astrology They asked change readings person surprised reading Doesn disprove astrology Not Suppose student standard accepted psychological test horoscope readings told test Wouldn answers Would disproved standard accepted psychological test What Randi demonstrated people gullible easily fooled The validity astrology Other researchers careful There article July 1995 edition Skeptical Inquirer magazine years titled Did Moon Sink Titanic The author Richard Branham examined dates disasters sea sign position Moon correlation Unfortunately author astrologer knowledge claimed Another strawman fallacy Had author time study astrology bothered study Some years earlier study published based examination thousands cases correlation whatsoever occupation Sun sign abnormally large number lawyers born Gemini Once astrologer worth salt assertion One case strawman fallacy The step evaluation subject effort learn Only analyzed criticized Hopefully lessons website process started Astrology Skepticism ZodiacPage
